A prospect emails you a screenshot of a ChatGPT answer about your business, with one line highlighted: “Why does ChatGPT say this about you?” That happened to a business owner who wrote about it on Reddit. ChatGPT was quoting a forum post from 2021, one that Google had buried years ago. Search had moved on. The AI answer hadn’t.
Here’s why AI engines show an old version of a business, what that owner did right, what changed 30 days later, and how to keep watching it. We also asked three engines about our own brand, and the answers were mixed.
Read the transcript
0:00 "Why does ChatGPT say this about you?"
A business owner on Reddit got an email from a prospect: "Why does ChatGPT say this about you?" ChatGPT was quoting a forum post from 2021, buried on Google long ago, but still alive in AI answers.
0:16 Why AI shows an old version of you
Across four AI engines, they found three sources behind the old picture: that thread, an outdated profile on another site, and their own About page, written before their last product change.
0:28 Can't reproduce it? It isn't gone
Can't reproduce it? That doesn't mean it's gone. Answers change by engine, location and account, and from one run to the next. Get the prospect's exact wording, then ask signed out or in a private window, several times, on every engine.
0:46 Trying it on our own brand
Here's that check on our own brand, asked signed out: is AEO Ultimate legit? ChatGPT answers, and shows the sources it used. Perplexity and Gemini each answer from their own set of sources. Same question, three engines, three different pictures. Read what they cite, not just what they say.
1:11 What they did right
Then they did the right things: updated the pages they control, claimed the profile, fixed old bios, and published one page answering the thread's question. They left the forum post alone. You rarely win by burying a source. You win by giving the engines a better one.
1:28 Thirty days later
Thirty days later, Perplexity had dropped the old profile, and Gemini was using the new About page. ChatGPT still mentioned the thread, just lower down. AI Overviews barely moved. Each engine updates on its own schedule.
1:44 Why you can't prove what caused it
Can they prove their edits caused it? No, and they said so. Answers vary, engines update on their own, and several things changed at once. The honest claim is: this was there before, and this is there now.
1:58 What to do next
Next: earn fresh mentions on other sites, like reviews and articles. If the forum allows it, add a current update to the old thread. And ask category questions that don't name you, to see whether you show up at all.
2:13 Check weekly, judge monthly
Keep checking every week, because cited sources change between runs, even on the same engine. Ask the same questions each time, and judge the trend over a month, not a single week.
2:25 Tracking it in AEO Ultimate
In AEO Ultimate, AI visibility asks your questions across up to eight AI engines in one click. Profiles on your Company profile are published as sameAs, and count as you here. These are real results for aeoultimate.com.
2:41 See which sources the AI used
Each run shows who was cited instead of you and the pages other sites wrote about you. From the second run on, you get a trend. That tells you what's out of date. Fixing it is still work, yours or someone you hire.

Why does ChatGPT show an outdated version of my business?
Because AI engines answer from whatever sources they can find about you, and old sources don’t expire. The owner asked ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Google’s AI Overviews the same four questions: their brand name, “is X legit”, “X reviews” and “X vs competitor”. Three sources were behind the old picture:
- An old forum thread from 2021, which two of the engines used.
- An outdated profile on another site.
- Their own About page, still describing the company as it was before its last product change.
That last one is easy to miss. Your own pages count too. We saw it on our own site: ChatGPT built part of its answer about us from one of our own comparison pages. Whatever your pages say, the engines repeat, so keep them current.
Why can’t I see the answer my prospect saw?
Because AI answers change with the engine, the person’s location, whether they’re signed in, what the assistant remembers about them, and simply from one run to the next. Not being able to reproduce it doesn’t mean it’s gone. It may show up in one answer in five, and your prospect saw that one.
- Get the prospect’s exact wording, or their screenshot.
- Ask it again signed out or in a private window, so your own account and history don’t shape the answer.
- Ask several times, on every engine: ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Google’s AI Overviews at least.
- Add the question to the ones you track every week, so you see it if it comes back.
What do AI engines say about our own brand?
We tried it on ourselves. On October 29, 2026, signed out, we asked ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini the same question: “Is AEO Ultimate legit?” Same question, three engines, three different pictures, each built from different sources.



All three are fair. We are new, and we don’t have customer reviews yet, which no page we publish can fix. Your answers will differ from ours, and from one day to the next. That’s the point: read what each engine cites, not just what it says. The sources are your to-do list.
How do you fix what AI says about your business?
You give the engines better sources. Here’s what the owner did, and it’s the right order:
- Fix what you own. They updated their own pages, starting with the About page.
- Make your details match everywhere. They claimed the outdated profile and fixed old bios, so every source describes the business the same way.
- Answer the old question better. They published one new page answering the question the forum thread was answering.
- Leave the old source alone. They didn’t try to bury or remove the forum post. You rarely win by burying a source. You win by giving the engines a better one.
How long does it take for AI answers to change?
It varies by engine, because each one updates on its own schedule. Thirty days after the owner’s changes:
- Perplexity had stopped using the old profile.
- Gemini was picking up the new About page.
- ChatGPT still mentioned the forum thread, just lower down.
- Google’s AI Overviews looked almost the same.
Can you prove your changes fixed it?
No, and the owner said so. The same question gives different answers, engines update on their own, and several things changed at once, so there is nothing to compare against. The honest claim is the one they made: this was there before, and this is there now. Anyone who promises to “fix ChatGPT” is promising more than anyone can show.
What should you do next?
- Earn fresh mentions on other sites: reviews, articles and partner pages. Engines trust what others say about you more than what you say about yourself.
- Add a current update to the old thread, if the forum allows it, so the outdated source carries its own correction.
- Ask category questions that don’t name you, such as “best X for Y”. They show whether you appear at all, which matters more than how you’re described once someone already knows your name.
How often should you check what AI says about you?
Every week, and judge the trend over a month. Cited sources change between runs, even on the same engine, so a monthly snapshot can miss a bad source coming and going. Keep the questions the same every time: your name, “is X legit”, “X reviews”, “X vs competitor”, plus a few category questions. For checks by hand, always ask signed out or in a private window.
In AEO Ultimate, AI Visibility asks your questions across up to eight AI engines in one click, on your own API keys. Profiles you add to your Company profile are published as sameAs in your schema, and count as you in the results. Each run shows who was cited instead of you and the pages other sites wrote about you, which is where an outdated profile shows up. From the second run on, you also get a trend.


Monitoring tells you what’s out of date. Fixing it is still work, yours or someone you hire.
Related: How can I tell whether AI assistants are citing my website? · AI Visibility guide · 5 things to get cited by AI
Owner of Tampa Web Technologies Inc. and Creator of AEO Ultimate
David Chamberlain is an SEO, AEO, and GEO specialist with 17 years of experience in digital optimization. He holds a professional certification in AI Fluency: Framework & Foundations, issued by Anthropic Education, an educational division of Anthropic. Chamberlain currently owns his own business focused on search and optimization services.